8 replies to this topic

[alereflammam]

Any feedback on Pulse TI vs Step Black?

I have Tuuks and my step black is going to need replacing soon. Is it worth it to move to Pulse Ti and keep my tuuks or move to XS holders and Step Black?

[Golden Gate Sharpening]

The Pulse TI is quality steel. I've only used it a few times, but sharpen many pairs and they hold an edge very well. It's not on the level of Step Black, but is Bauer's best offering so far. It does scratch up a bit more than the Step Black, but nothing substantial. I've seen like-new/very good condition sets pop up second hand for as low as $60-$70. Also something to keep in mind: Bauer is coming out with a new holder next year. Their old steel will be compatible with these new holders, but the new steel will not be compatible with Edge holders. 

 

Do you prefer a stiffer holder or something more flexible? Edge holders are softer and more flexible, whereas the XS holders are more stiff and rigid. The difference isn't drastic, but is noticeable when skating hard, especially on turns. If you've liked the Edge holders and haven't had any issues with them, I'd leave them on. You can always buy the Step Blacksteel sets that pop up from time to time on SLS/eBay. If you are dead set on having multiple sets of Step Blacksteel and/or like the idea of a more robust holder, you can have the XS installed. 

[alereflammam]

This is great info. Thanks Jake!

[iceman8310]

The Pulse TI is quality steel. I've only used it a few times, but sharpen many pairs and they hold an edge very well. It's not on the level of Step Black, but is Bauer's best offering so far. It does scratch up a bit more than the Step Black, but nothing substantial. I've seen like-new/very good condition sets pop up second hand for as low as $60-$70. Also something to keep in mind: Bauer is coming out with a new holder next year. Their old steel will be compatible with these new holders, but the new steel will not be compatible with Edge holders.

Do you prefer a stiffer holder or something more flexible? Edge holders are softer and more flexible, whereas the XS holders are more stiff and rigid. The difference isn't drastic, but is noticeable when skating hard, especially on turns. If you've liked the Edge holders and haven't had any issues with them, I'd leave them on. You can always buy the Step Blacksteel sets that pop up from time to time on SLS/eBay. If you are dead set on having multiple sets of Step Blacksteel and/or like the idea of a more robust holder, you can have the XS installed.

What’s the advantages of a stiffer holder vs. a more soft holder?

[Golden Gate Sharpening]

What’s the advantages of a stiffer holder vs. a more soft holder?

 

Preference. The Edge holders flex a bit on tight turns, transactions, stops, etc while the XS holders are more firm. It's not a drastic difference, but it is something to consider if you're going all-in on new boots and holders. 

[iceman8310]

Preference. The Edge holders flex a bit on tight turns, transactions, stops, etc while the XS holders are more firm. It's not a drastic difference, but it is something to consider if you're going all-in on new boots and holders.

Is there any loss in performance?

[Golden Gate Sharpening]

Like I said before, it's a preference. The performance of the holders is based on the individual player and their skating style, skills, and preferences. One holder does not perform "better" than the others. 

[Miller55]

It's all about feel. The true holders are stiff and I tried them but had to go back to LS because of that extra but of give that I've just gotten used to and expect when I cut hard

[ntwusc]

I’ve been looking at Step Blacksteel prices and have seen that some sites list JRZ and Step as interchangeable. Is CCM having Step manufacture for JRZ? Was Step sold to JRZ? I can’t find much info anywhere.